Free PDF The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop
When obtaining this e-book The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop as recommendation to review, you could get not simply inspiration however additionally new expertise as well as lessons. It has more than usual perks to take. What type of publication that you read it will be valuable for you? So, why ought to obtain this book qualified The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop in this short article? As in link download, you can obtain the e-book The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop by on the internet.
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop
Free PDF The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop
Locate more experiences as well as knowledge by reviewing the book qualified The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop This is a book that you are looking for, isn't it? That corrects. You have involved the best website, after that. We consistently provide you The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop as well as the most favourite books worldwide to download and install and appreciated reading. You may not overlook that seeing this collection is a function and even by unexpected.
Why ought to be this publication The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop to review? You will certainly never ever obtain the understanding and experience without getting by on your own there or attempting by on your own to do it. Thus, reviewing this e-book The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop is required. You can be great and correct enough to obtain just how essential is reading this The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop Also you consistently read by commitment, you could support yourself to have reading e-book habit. It will certainly be so helpful and enjoyable then.
However, exactly how is the way to get this book The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop Still confused? It matters not. You can delight in reviewing this e-book The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop by on-line or soft data. Merely download guide The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop in the link offered to check out. You will obtain this The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop by online. After downloading and install, you can save the soft file in your computer system or gizmo. So, it will certainly reduce you to read this publication The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop in particular time or location. It may be uncertain to take pleasure in reviewing this e-book The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop, because you have great deals of task. Yet, with this soft documents, you can enjoy checking out in the downtime even in the gaps of your works in workplace.
Once again, reading habit will certainly consistently offer beneficial advantages for you. You could not require to invest sometimes to review guide The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop Merely set apart several times in our spare or spare times while having dish or in your workplace to read. This The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop will certainly show you new point that you could do now. It will assist you to enhance the top quality of your life. Occasion it is merely a fun e-book The African Origin Of Civilization: Myth Or Reality The African Origin Of Civilization, By Cheikh Anta Diop, you could be healthier and a lot more enjoyable to appreciate reading.
The author presents documentary evidence supporting his theory that Egyptian civilization was of Black origin
Title: The African Origin of Civilization
Author: Diop, Cheikh Anta
Publisher: Independent Pub Group
Publication Date: 1974/03/01
Number of Pages:
Binding Type: PAPERBACK
Library of Congress: 73081746
- Sales Rank: #1450558 in Books
- Published on: 1974
- Binding: Paperback
Most helpful customer reviews
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
Much ado and many words to ultimately say nothing at all
By Leib Gershon Mitchell
There are lots of problems with this book from the outset:
1 The age/ quality of the sources:
a. This book was put together from some older publications. The dates listed in the front matter of the book are 1955 and 1967. It is also stated in the conclusion that the book would not be updated (p. 276-- "It is therefore understandable why we never rewrite a work once it has been published.").
b. In the time since the book was printed (shortly after the crystal structure of DNA was solved), genetic fingerprinting has been developed as well as the concept of haplotypes/ haplogroups.
c. Therefore, the things that this book relies on (anecdotal evidence and paintings) could be ignored in favor of actual genetic data..
d. Most of the reviews on this book were written years after molecular genetics had reached its maturity, and that makes me wonder if most people have treated this as a science or if they are using this in the same way that a Jihadist uses his Quran.
e. So many anthropologists. So many historical sources translated two and three times between different languages.
f. The sources seem to be mainly philosophers (e.g, Karl Marx), linguists, and anthropologists (e.g., Leakey). The fact that there are no molecular geneticists can be attributed to the fact that that field had not reached its maturity yet-- but it does not excuse the fact that the book is just empirically wrong.
2. The notion of race:
a. Either you believe that race is "socially constructed" or that it exists in reality.
b. In the case that you believe the first, then what is the point of this book? If there is no such thing as a black/ white/ Asian race, then they can't exist to build societies/ countries, can they?
c. In the case that you believe the second idea (that race has biological and physical reality), then it's much easier to find *current* genetic evidence that is produced by people who can actually produce it in large quantities (i.e., molecular geneticists--real scientists).
d. He cites Richard Leakey from the beginning (xv) as saying that human beings have monogenetic origins. (Leakey is an anthropologist who died before genetic fingerprinting could be born.) How did Leakey know this? Leakey is quoted again and again throughout the book.
3. Consistency with reality:
a. In Spencer Wells The Journey of Man: A Genetic Odyssey, the problems of man's genetic origin is already solved (again! molecular genetics). It directly refutes what this author is saying.
b. Does this thesis really make sense? (The point of a thesis is to explain extant data and NOT to create a narrative.) The Sahara Desert is something like 2983 miles from North to South. Smaller geographic obstacles have created much larger gaps between genetic populations. (North and South Chinese. North and South Indians. East and West Africans.)
4. Philosophical and Conceptual Issues:
a. Ok, so black people created Egypt. So now what. If you take it as a given that blacks really created and ran Egypt, then what does that have to do with problems that modern Africans are facing today? (HIV/AIDS. Infant Mortality. Political instability.)
b. If the Africans of then were so good at statecraft, then why are the ones of today having such problems getting it right?
c. If Africans of yesterday developed a system as good as what was in Egypt, then why didn't they steamroll over the whole African continent (and parts of Europe, too), turning them in the Black Egyptians? (China started out much smaller than it is today, and they crushed everything that was in their way until China became as big as it is now.)
d. If Greek and Egyptian society were of African origin, does that really have anything to do with modern times? Singapore is a society of Chinese origin (and some people have said that it is the most successful Chinese society in the last several thousand years), but Singapore of today is miles apart from the China of Qinshihuang.
5. The prose:
I think it's been said that "If academic writings were difficult because of the deep thoughts involved, that might be understandable, even if frustrating. Seldom is that the case, however. Jaw-breaking words often cover up very sloppy thinking." Truer words never spoken than in this case.
There is also no index in the book.
Verdict: Not worth the money. Not worth the time. Genetics has gone a long way since the time of this book, and a person would be best served by catching up with those advances.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Five Stars
By May
I love learning my history.
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop PDF
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop EPub
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop Doc
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop iBooks
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop rtf
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop Mobipocket
The African Origin of Civilization: Myth or Reality The African Origin of Civilization, by Cheikh Anta Diop Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar